The lesson is simple: capable and honest managers can find themselves in difficulty when they fail to apply sufficient scrutiny in areas outside their expertise.
Fraud Week is an important reminder that fraud is not just an accounting problem. It is also an employment, governance, and leadership issue.
At its core, fraud involves a breakdown of trust, and trust sits at the heart of every employment relationship. While fraud is often associated with dishonest employees, the consequences can extend well beyond the individual who commits it. Managers, supervisors, and decision-makers may also face scrutiny when warning signs are missed or oversight falls short.
One of New Zealand's most significant workplace fraud cases involved Joanne Harrison, a former senior manager at the Ministry of Transport. Through the use of fictitious entities and false documentation, significant payments were made to organisations associated with her over an extended period. The matter ultimately resulted in criminal prosecution, imprisonment, and the end of her employment.
The case is often remembered as a story of dishonesty, but it also highlights a broader workplace lesson. Fraud frequently succeeds because organisations place trust in people who appear competent, credible, and authoritative. Over time, colleagues stop asking questions because they assume someone else already has.
The employment law consequences of fraud can be severe. Where dishonesty is established, employers may be justified in pursuing disciplinary action that leads to summary dismissal for serious misconduct. Recovery of losses and referral to law enforcement may also follow. The consequences often extend beyond employment, affecting careers, reputations, professional registrations, and future opportunities.
However, not every employment risk arises from deliberate dishonesty.
At BuckettLaw, we recently acted in a matter that illustrates this point. While the facts have been generalised to preserve confidentiality, the manager involved was not accused of personally benefiting from any wrongdoing. They were an experienced operational leader who relied heavily on financial information provided by others. With hindsight, information that should have attracted further scrutiny was accepted at face value.
The result was not criminal prosecution, but it did lead to a disciplinary process, significant stress, and concerns about the manager's future employment.
The lesson is simple: capable and honest managers can find themselves in difficulty when they fail to apply sufficient scrutiny in areas outside their expertise.
Many organisations promote people into management because they are excellent practitioners or strong leaders. What often follows is an assumption that they also possess the financial skills necessary to oversee budgets, approve expenditure, manage procurement, and exercise appropriate governance oversight.
That assumption can be dangerous.
Managers approving expenditure or overseeing budgets need enough financial literacy to recognise when something does not look right. Employers also have a responsibility to ensure managers receive appropriate training and support before placing them in positions of financial accountability.
Common warning signs include:
Suppliers that cannot be independently verified.
Repeated invoices just below approval thresholds.
Pressure to approve payments urgently.
Missing supporting documentation.
Resistance to procurement processes.
Unexplained changes to supplier details.
Excessive control of a process by one employee or contractor.
Undisclosed relationships with suppliers or contractors.
Inconsistent financial reporting.
Requests for exceptions to established controls.
None of these factors necessarily indicate fraud, but each should prompt further enquiry.
The most expensive question in any workplace is often the one that was never asked.
Professional scepticism is not cynicism. It is not an accusation of wrongdoing. It is simply the discipline of verifying information before relying on it. The manager who asks one additional question today may avoid becoming the subject of an investigation tomorrow.
Employees also have a role to play. Fraud prevention is not solely the responsibility of directors, executives, finance teams, or managers. Employees who encounter suspicious transactions, unexplained payments, false documentation, conflicts of interest, or other unusual conduct should raise concerns through appropriate channels.
Turning a blind eye can create risks of its own. Employees who knowingly ignore suspicious conduct, fail to disclose significant concerns, or help conceal information may find their own actions scrutinised during a subsequent investigation.
Strong workplace cultures are built on accountability, transparency, and a willingness to speak up. If something does not look right, do not assume somebody else will deal with it. Ask questions. Raise concerns. Follow the appropriate process.
The employment law lessons are straightforward:
Dishonesty almost always leads to serious employment consequences.
Managers can face employment risk even where they receive no personal benefit if they fail to exercise reasonable oversight.
Employers should ensure managers receive appropriate training and support before making them responsible for financial decisions.
Trust remains essential, but trust without verification creates unnecessary risk.
During Fraud Week, perhaps the most important question any manager can ask is:
"Do I know enough about this transaction to be comfortable defending my decision if it is scrutinised six months from now?"
If the answer is no, stop, ask questions, and seek advice before proceeding.
Fraud prevention is not the responsibility of the finance team alone. It is everyone's responsibility.